Fact check: No Evidence That University of Michigan Professor Praised Indian Culture, Viral Post Debunked

 

By: Rahul Thakur 

Recently, a news report clip has been circulating on social media that claims to quote Dr. Eric Geddes, a Professor of Sociology at the University of Michigan. According to the report, he said, "By copying my country, India lost its joint family, culture, and social prosperity… and by neglecting the elders, it got addiction and loneliness.”

Is it true?

This is a misleading news report. The University of Michigan has confirmed that no person named Eric Geddes has worked as a Professor of Sociology. Additionally, the image used in the report is of another academician, Peter Clarkson, a Professor of Accounting and Finance at the University of Queensland, Australia. We were also unable to find any credible news sources reporting the statements mentioned in the image that is being circulated. 

How did we find out the truth?

An image of the claim used as a WhatsApp status

First, we ran a reverse image search of the newspaper clipping with the help of Google Lens, which led to several social media posts on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter sharing the same image. Some of these posts show an e-paper clipping of the news report, which shows that it was published on 8 August 2022 in the Dainik Bhaskar (Indore city) edition.

We were able to confirm this by spotting the news report on the epaper edition of the Dainik Bhaskar (Indore city)published on August 8, 2022. However, the report does not give details about whether these statements were made in a public event or an exclusive interview with the reporter, except that the said academician was on a personal visit to India. 

Screenshot of a tweet with the claim

City Bhaskar Indore (8th August, 2022) Epaper

To find if this was from a public event, we searched for other news media coverage in Indore about the person during the time. We were not able to find any other reports quoting this person during that time. We have emailed Dainik Bhaskar, Indore, for details and will update the story once we get a response.  

Further, we contacted the University of Michigan to verify the institutional affiliation of the person mentioned in the report. Brian Taylor, Communications Manager with the Office of Public Affairs, University of Michigan, confirmed that there is no record of such a person having worked at the University of Michigan since 2001. "The university has no record of the individual referenced in your email as having been employed at the University of Michigan", he said over email.

News report from the University of Queensland featuring Professor Peter Clarkson, whose image was misidentified as 'Dr. Eric Geddes' in the viral post.

When we ran a search for the image given in the news report, we found that the same image was used in a news report on the University of Queensland's website in 2019. According to the report, the person in the photograph is Professor Peter Clarkson, a Professor of Accounting and Finance with the University of Queensland, Australia. 

We have reached out to Professor Peter Clarkson via email to verify whether he visited India during the stated period or made the statements cited in the news report. We will update the story upon receiving a response.

Conclusion: We conclude that the Dainik Bhaskar news report, which claims that a Professor of Sociology at the University of Michigan lauded Indian cultural values, is misleading. Our investigation found that no such academician has been affiliated with the University of Michigan, and the photograph used in the report is of a different academician whose field of expertise is not sociology. Moreover, there are no reports from credible news organisations corroborating the statement.

Fact-Check: Unrelated, Old Video Falsely Shared as Footage of Pahalgam Attackers

By: Aditya Veer Singh

Note: At the time of publishing this fact-check, the Instagram account was active. However, the user has later deleted the account where the original video was present.

A video posted on the Instagram account @Sadiq999 by a user from Azerbaijan on April 11, 2025, is being circulated on social media with the false claim that it shows the attackers involved in the recent terror attack in Pahalgam, India. However, the video has no connection to the incident in Pahalgam.

A short video showing a group of individuals travelling in a car is being shared on social media with the sketch of terrorists of the Pahalgam attack, where users have linked it to the terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam on 22 April. 

Some users shared the clip after the terror attack, saying that " These are the dogs who shot after making them recite the Kalma! The bastards are celebrating now." (The original post can be seen here, and the archived version can be seen here)

Is it true? :

No, the claim is misleading. The video is old and has existed on the internet since April 11, 2025, by the Instagram account (_Sadiq999_), which is based in Azerbaijan. It has no connection to the Pahalgam terror attack. (Link to the original Instagram Post)

How did we find out the truth? :

We used Google Lens to take a screenshot of one of the keyframes from the video, which led us to a post with a section of this clip shared by an Insta page called "sadiq999_." 

We also came across the original version of the video, which was shared on Instagram.

The caption associated with the original post includes some promotional text in the Russian Language. A Google translated version of the text on the post reads, "The BMW E46 M3 CSL front springs are one coil shorter than the stock M3, and the springs and dampers have been retuned at each corner to account for the car's lighter weight. Both compression and rebound damping were changed in the process. Visit shop. BIMMERtips.com for genuine BMW parts, aftermarket parts, dealer brochures, vintage magazine ads, posters and more. FREE SHIPPING On all US orders. Link in bio. Visit BIMMERtips.com for paint codes, wheel style guides and other helpful reference information in addition to helpful tips and tricks. Link in bio."

The account tagged as "Content Creator" in its about section has been active on Instagram since February 2024.

 While we could not independently verify the location of the video, past content from the handle and the presence of the same individuals in the older videos from the handle, along with the descriptions of the posts, indicate  that the video has no connection to the terror attack in Pahalgam. 

Conclusion: An old, unrelated video is being shared with the claim that this is the group of terrorists who are responsible for the terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir's  Pahalgam on 22 April 2025.

Fact-Check: Bilaspur 'Attack' Debunked as Scuffle Over Headlights, Not Religion

By: Shikha Yadav

A claim was made on X from the account @SanatanPrabhat that a Hindu man was attacked by an Islamist mob in the Bilaspur district of Chhattisgarh turned out to be a scuffle of two individuals about dipping the headlight of the car as per the fact-check carried out based on the police records. The post on X shows a video and a few pictures of the victim and links to their website article about the same incident presenting the same claim.

 

Screenshots of articles in Organiser and Sanatan Prabhat

The article linked to the X post claims that the victim of the attack was wearing a tulsi garland and the assailants, attacked him after mistaking his name for a particular religious identity. According to the report, the victim went to the police station and filed a complaint. However, no other relevant information like the date of filing the First Information Report (FIR) was mentioned in the article.

Further inspection of the X post pointed to a watermark (@subhi_karma) in the video attached. A page has been found on X with this ID of Subhi Vishwakarma, who published a ground report in Organiser, the RSS mouthpiece about the incident. The link to the article was shared by the X user in the same thread.

The Organiser report also puts forward similar claims with some additional ones that a friend of the victim was present in the vehicle who belonged to the same religion as the assailants intervened only after the victim sustained serious injuries. 

However, the Organiser report also shares the details of the First Information Report (FIR number: 419/2024) filed by the victim at the Civil Lines police station in Bilaspur on May 7. Though an image of the FIR was given along with the report, details were not readable in the image. 

Utilising the online FIR search database of Chattisgarh Police, the original FIR of the incident was retrieved. Upon inspection, it was found that the communal angle of the incident as mentioned in the reports of the Organiser and the Sanatan Prabhat and the social media handles was not true.

After going through the FIR, it was found that the reason for the attack was an argument related to dipping the headlights of the car following which the attackers thrashed the victim, not due to Tulsi garland as stated in the articles. There is no mention in the FIR regarding arguments over the religious identities of the people involved. The FIR also shows that the friend of the victim wasn't seated back and reacted late instead he intervened and witnessed the whole incident and helped in identifying the attackers.

Hence, the viral claim is false and tries to incite highly dangerous communal angles with the use of exaggerated and manipulated facts.

Fact-check: Viral Video Alleging Gorilla-Like Human Birth in Bangladesh Actually Shows Gorilla Birth at Fort Worth Zoo

 

By: Sayan Bhaskar

A viral video which is being circulated on social media, claiming that a woman in Thakurgaon district, Bangladesh, gave birth to a child resembling a gorilla, has been proven false. The misleading video, initially posted by the Facebook user Sahed Ahmed, garnered an overwhelming response, accumulating 54k reactions, 2.7k comments, and amassing 8.9 million views before it was deleted from the platform. However, the same video continues circulating on other platforms such as YouTube (Link) and Instagram (Link).

Verification and Findings

Frames from the viral video were extracted and analyzed using reverse image search tools. These searches revealed that the footage originally came from an Instagram post by the Fort Worth Zoo, based in Texas, USA.

The comparison of the viral video ( left) and the Instagram post of Fortworth Zoo(right)

Upon closer examination, it was revealed that the video showcased the birth of a gorilla baby, which bore a striking resemblance to the one depicted in the false claim. Notably, the background setting and the holding cloth observed in the gorilla birth footage mirrored those seen in the misleading video circulating on social media platforms.

The comparison of the viral video ( left) and the Instagram post of Fortworth Zoo(right)

The original video was found on the Fort Worth Zoo’s official Instagram account. Posted earlier than the viral Facebook claim, the video documents the birth of a gorilla at the zoo, not a human baby. The zoo’s Instagram reel clearly shows a newborn gorilla, debunking any connection to a human birth in Bangladesh.

The claim that a woman in Thakurgaon district, Bangladesh, gave birth to a gorilla-like child is false. The video in question depicts a gorilla birth at the Fort Worth Zoo. This incident highlights the ease with which misinformation can spread on social media platforms and underscores the importance of verifying the authenticity of sensational claims.

हिमाचल में वढ़ रहे अनुसूचित जाति के विरूद्ध मामले।

By Abhishek Kumar

हिमाचल प्रदेश में अनुसूचित जाति के विरूद्ध दर्ज मामलों में एसटी/एससी अधिनियम के तेहद काफी इजाफा हुआ है। हमने पिछले दस वर्षों 2011-2020 तक के आंकड़ों का विश्लेषण करने पर यह पाया की वर्ष 2019-20 के दौरान अनुसूचित जाति के लोगों के विरूद्ध किए जाने वाले अपराधों की दर में 32.21 प्रतिशत की वृद्धि दर्ज की गई।  इन आंकड़ों के अनुसार सिर्फ तीन (3) वर्षों यानी 2014,2015 और 2017 के अलावा अन्य दिन वर्षों में वृद्धि पाई गईं। 2012 में वर्ष 2011 की अपेक्षा 37.23 प्रतिशत यानी कुल 129 मामले दर्ज किए गए। वहीं वर्ष  2020 में दर्ज कुल मामलों कि संख्या 250 जो कि वर्ष 2014 की तुलना में 32.27 प्रतिशत अधिक थी। समाजिक न्याय अधिकारिता विभाग के द्वारा प्रकाशित एक रिपोर्ट के अनुसार अनुसूचित जातियों की संख्या हिमाचल प्रदेश में 57 है। अतः अनुसूचित जाति के विरूद्ध दर्ज होने वाले मामलों में लगभग दोगुनी बढ़ोतरी हुई है।

https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/IcdtM/3/

Number of Juvenile Rape Convicts in India declines : NCRB data

Representative Image

By: Gargi Sud

India recorded a steep decline in the number of juvenile rape convicts over the past 8 years (2012-2020) according to the data provided by the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB). While this decline is reflected across all the age groups that qualify as juvenile, the prominent decline is seen among the age group of 16 to 18 years.

In 2020, 777 juveniles in the aforementioned age group were convicted of rape crimes. The year recorded the lowest convictions for the age groups below 12 and below 16 as well. The total convictions in the below 18 year age group for the year 2020 was 1022. This marked a 26.10 percentage decline as compared to the figure in 2019.

After the Delhi gang rape case, the number of cases being reported increased which increased the number of convicts (for all age groups) as well. The definition of who is a juvenile changed in the year 2015 under the Juvenile Justice Act where the age was reduced from 18 to 16. Initially a decline was seen in the number as a total of 1337 juveniles were convicted in 2015. But in 2016, this number increased to 1561 for the age group 16-18 reflecting a 16.75 percentage increase. Since then, there was a continuous decline in the number of juvenile convicts of rape crime, specifically in the age group 16 to 18 years.

 

2020 which marked the steep decline was apparently the year of the COVID-19 outbreak as well. Some observers attribute the nationwide lockdowns imposed during the various phases of the COVID-19 virus outbreak as the reason for the decline in number of juvenile rape convicts. However, others point out that it could be a case of cases not being reported.

“Lockdown can be a reason of the decline but rape cases not being reported are a major reason. 50-60% of the convictions decreases due to victim changing statements under societal pressure and due to lack of family support,” said Mr. Krishan Rana who is working with Gunjan, a NGO working for women and child empowerment in Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh.

According to a police official in Dharamshala, children below 18 years of age are exposed to a lot of peer pressure and are curious to know about new things and experiment them. They suggested that it is important for parents to have a friendly relation with children and to counsel them at different points of time.

The official also stated that it is often seen that the victims change their original statements and often refuse to identify the arrested culprits leading to dismissal of the case without conviction.

Rana also point out that unrestricted use of gadgets and the access to inappropriate content through the gadgets could be one reason for juveniles committing such crimes. “The child should be made aware about the appropriate content from the very beginning. There should be a proper timing for the children to use a gadget under parental check. Parental locks should be used. I have taken a parental lock for my child because it is parent’s responsibility to keep a check on the content and apps being used by the child,” says he.

According to him, the laws to prevent sexual assault need to be strict in both juvenile as well as adult cases. “Sixteen is a bigger age since there are a lot of cases reported from schools especially in metro cities. There is a need for strict ruling and guidelines. 6 months rehabilitation period will not have much impact on a rapist so the rehabilitation term should be increased to 1-2 years,” he said.

However, imprisonment may not be the most effective correctional measure for juvenile convicts. According to Rana, a juvenile rape convict should not be sent to the adult jail as it increases their chances of getting “exploited” by adult criminals. “Juvenile rehabilitation centers should be properly inspected by the government to avoid any societal discrimination and there must be provisions for education of the convicts”, said he.

Himachal Pradesh ranks fifth in Women Literacy in India

Representative image credits: Unsplash

By: Shrishti Chaubey

According to the latest figures from National Family Health Survey (NFHS), Himachal Pradesh stands at 5th position in women literacy in India with 91.7% percentage of women in the state being literate. Kerala tops the list with 98.3% literate women followed by Lakshadweep with 96.5%. While Mizoram stood at 94.4%, Goa secured 4th position with 93%.

The national average in women literacy in 2019-21 stands at 78.97%. A total of 18 states/UTs fall below the national average in the percentage of women who are literate. Bihar with 57.8% has the least percentage of women literacy followed by Jharkhand being the second-worst player with 61.7%. 

 

Districts of Himachal Pradesh recorded better results as compared to the national average since 7 out of 12 districts scored more than 90% whereas the other 5 districts scored more than 83%. Hamirpur attained the first position with 94.80% and Kangra being the second competitor with 94.40% followed by Mandi having 94%. Chamba was the worst performer among all scoring 84.10% followed by Sirmaur with 84.90%. Plain regions like Kangra and Una performed well as compared to tribal and upper regions (Kinnaur, Lahaul and Spiti, and Chamba) of Himachal Pradesh. According to NFHS methods, women who completed  9th standard schooling or higher educational qualification and can read a whole sentence or part of a sentence is considered literate.

National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5) is the fifth series of surveys which is prepared by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India which aims to provide information on the population, health, and nutrition in each state and union territory in India. NFHS-5 is divided into two phases, where phase-I is conducted in 2019-20 for 22 states/UTs and phase-II in 2019-21 for 14 states/UTs.

 

The NFHS-5 survey for Himachal Pradesh was conducted from 16 July 2019 to 5 November 2019 by Population Research Center, Himachal Pradesh University, Shimla. The fact sheet provides information from 10,368 women aged 15-49 years.